Spirituality: Difference between revisions

From metawiki
No edit summary
 
(63 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
Spirituality is defined here as the personal pursuit of one's core beliefs and connections to the [[universe]], and attempts to become more mentally attuned to those beliefs and connections. It is separated fully from belief in the [[supernatural]] in order to create a "[[secular]] spirituality" that is compatible with [[science]].
[[File:Spirituality-Sacred-Divine-Beauty-Secular-Faith.jpg|thumb|Sacred Geometry Evokes Spirituality]]
Spirituality is defined here as the personal pursuit of one's core [[beliefs]], our [[connections]] to the human [[community]] and the [[universe]], and our efforts to help ourselves live in accordance with those [[convictions]] and [[connections]].


== It's All In Your Brain ==
This definition of spirituality has no implied [[belief]] in the [[supernatural]], in order to allow for "[[secular]] spirituality" that is compatible with [[science]]. <blockquote>''"Where are our souls created during the [[big bang]]"''  


Since the source of all [[morality]], and indeed [[consciousness]] itself, is the [[brain]], most "spiritual" pursuits involve attempts to become more in touch with the internal reward systems of our [[brains]].
''"It depends on what you mean by 'our souls'"''


[[Buddhism]] is a spiritual [[tradition]] that is almost completely [[psychological]] in terms of its practices.  
''"You know what I mean by our souls."''  -[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oldD8K8_o44 Philomena Cunk and Brian Cox] </blockquote>In case you don't know what they mean by our souls, try sounding it out loud. If that doesn't [[work]], this definition might help. The soul is the [[emergent property]] of [[consciousness]] that arises from the [[neurons]] in the [[brain]] and body, [[just]] [[like]] a hive is the [[emergent property]] of many bees [[working]] in concert. In general, spiritual terms tend to refer to [[emergent properties]] of [[complex systems]], which is why they seem so real to believers--because they are real things! Just not [[material]] objects. We now have the terminology and theories that allow us to examine these things [[Scientific|scientifically]].  


Spiritual [[tradition]] is [[ritualized]] [[mental health]], whether it is directly acknowledged as it is in [[Buddhism]] or indirectly as it is in Judeo-Christian [[traditions]].
For an academic lecture from this [[perspective]], watch [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jV253FLbXWs The Sciences of Emergent Complexity: Evolutionary Emergence of Body, Mind, and Spirituality] or one of the thousands of others like it.
 
== Spirituality Pages ==
An index of pages that discuss topics related to spirituality.
 
* '''[[Religion]]''', [[Belief systems|Belief Systems]], '''[[Dogma]]''', and [[Rituals]]
* [[Scripture]], [[Canon]], [[Literalism]], and '''[[Allegory]]'''
* '''[[Fractals]]''', '''[[Pantheism]]''', [[God]], and the [[God Concept|'''God Concept''']]
* [[Love]], [[Happiness]], '''[[Optimism]]''', and the [[Theory of everything|'''Theory of Everything''']]
* '''[[Universalism]]''' and the [[Universal in-group|'''Universal In-Group''']]
* [[Meaning of Life|'''Meaning of Life''']], [[Primal world beliefs]], [[The Gambler|'''The Gambler''']], and [[Enlightenment]]
* [[Truth]], [[Faith]], [[Authority]], and [[Trust]]
* '''[[Ethics]]''', [[Taboo]], and [[Outrage]]
* [[Suffering]] and '''[[Altruism]]'''
* [[Karma]], [[Heaven and Hell]], [[Death]] and the '''[[Afterlife]]'''
* [[Creation Story|'''Creation Story''']], [[Creationism]], and '''[[Evolution]]'''
* [[Apocalypse Prevention]]
* [[Atheism]] versus [[Pseudoscience]] and the [[Supernatural]]
* '''[[Secular]]''' [[Ethics]], [[Secular humanism|Secular Humanism]], and [[Secular institutions|Secular Institutions]]
* [[Wonder]] versus [[Woo]]
* '''[[Persuasion]]''' and [[Language]]
* '''[[Philosophy]]''' versus [[JP and JC]]
* [[Metaphor mapping|'''Metaphor Mapping''']]
* [[Manifestation|Stochastic Manifestation]] and the [[Sierpinski Trinity]]
* '''[[Art]]''', [[Poetry]], [[Music]], [[Humor]], and [[Aesthetics]]
* '''[[Psychedelics]]''', [[Variety]], and [[Neuroplasticity]]
* The [[Placebo effect|'''Placebo Effect''']]
 
It should also be noted that most of [[religion]] is simply intuitive, [[ritualized]], [[psychological]] therapy that leverages the [[placebo effect]]. Therefore, [[learning]] about the [[brain]] and the [[neuroscience]] of [[consciousness]] and [[happiness]] is also a spiritual pursuit.


== Spiritual Best Practices ==
== Spiritual Best Practices ==
Line 13: Line 42:
Modern spirituality borrows [[rituals]] and [[traditions]] from every [[culture]], as well as the [[science]] of [[psychology]], to create a patchwork of [[religious]], [[cultural]], and [[secular]] practices that can have widely varying degrees of success.
Modern spirituality borrows [[rituals]] and [[traditions]] from every [[culture]], as well as the [[science]] of [[psychology]], to create a patchwork of [[religious]], [[cultural]], and [[secular]] practices that can have widely varying degrees of success.


From this there needs to [[evolve]] a more purely [[evidence-based]] spiritual [[tradition]] that illuminates the intense [[beauty]] of the [[universe]] with the inspirational language of mysticism. One that taps the power of our ancestors and practices perfected over countless generations, while providing demonstrable value with its refined [[rituals]] based on spiritual and psychological [[best practices]].
From this there needs to [[evolve]] a more purely [[evidence-based]] spiritual [[tradition]] that illuminates the intense [[beauty]] of the [[universe]] with the [[inspirational]], [[poetic]] [[language]] of mysticism. One that taps the [[power]] of our ancestors and practices perfected over countless generations, while providing demonstrable value with its refined [[rituals]] based on spiritual and psychological [[best practices]].


== Secular Spirituality ==
== Secular Spirituality ==


Spirituality need not imply the [[supernatural]] and [[superstitious]]. It can be any pursuit of self-knowledge and mental self-improvement practice. An enlightened secular spirituality can find this knowledge in any source, while maintaining a healthy [[skepticism]] for spiritual [[grift|quackery]] that runs rampant when [[science]] and spirit are separate.
Spirituality need not imply the [[supernatural]] and [[superstitious]]. It can be any pursuit of [[Self-awareness|self-knowledge]] and [[mental]] [[self-improvement]] practice. An enlightened secular spirituality can find this knowledge in any source, while maintaining a [[healthy]] [[skepticism]] for spiritual [[Grift|quackery]] that runs rampant when [[science]] and spirit are separate.


Seeking to learn the [[science]] behind ancient practices like yoga, prayer and [[meditation]] is a spiritual pursuit. Understanding exactly how [[rituals]] affect our [[brains]] and bodies doesn't demystify them or negate the [[placebo effect]] that is at the root of many health benefits.  
Seeking to learn the [[science]] behind ancient practices like yoga, prayer and [[meditation]] is a spiritual pursuit. Understanding exactly how [[rituals]] affect our [[brains]] and bodies doesn't demystify them or negate the [[placebo effect]] that is at the root of many [[health]] benefits. <blockquote>''"I celebrate myself, and sing myself,''


While sometimes [[science]] will prove some cherished tradition to be ineffective or even counter-productive, it will back with the weight of evidence those that really help make our lives better and allow them to continue to be a part of our [[traditions]] when spiritual [[literalism]] has become a distant memory.
''And what I assume you shall assume,''


''For every atom belonging to me as good belongs to you."''
-[https://www.poetryfoundation.org/poems/45477/song-of-myself-1892-version Walt Whitman, Song of Myself]</blockquote>While sometimes [[science]] will prove some cherished tradition to be ineffective or even counter-productive, it will back with the weight of [[evidence]] those that really help make our lives better and allow them to continue to be a part of our [[traditions]] when spiritual [[literalism]] has become a distant memory.
[[File:Spiritual-Science-Venn-Diagram.png|none|thumb|650x650px|A Secular Spirituality Venn Diagram]]
== Woo Without Woo ==
The [[Brain|brain's]] desire for [[wonder]] often leads people to the [[supernatural]]. This causes [[secular]] and [[Scientific|scientifically]] minded people to refer to it derisively as "[[wikt:woo_woo|woo woo]]". [[Quantum woo]] is often use in attempts to add [[wonder]] to [[science]] by those who are unable to discern [[pseudoscience]] from [[reality]].
Is there a way to infuse [[science]] with [[wonder]] while still working within the limits of [[materialism]]?
[[Fractal]] [[Pantheism]] offers a viable solution. Using [[Fractal|fractal geometry]] and the [[universe]] itself as a [[scientific]] [[metaphor]] for the [[God Concept|god concept]], the [[beauty]] and [[wonder]] found in [[religious]] [[art]] and [[psychedelic]] visions throughout [[history]] is evoked, along with the infinite [[complexity]] of the [[evolving]] [[universe]], and the fundamental, [[Self-reference|self-referential]] slipperiness of [[truth]] described by [[Gödel]].
It uses a [[metaphor]] that helps ground spiritual [[beliefs]] in [[scientific]] [[reality]], instead of [[supernatural]] ones that are too easy to take [[literally]].
[[Fractals]] give the [[brain]] the [[wonder]] and "woo" that it craves while working fully within the framework of the [[laws of physics]].
== Secular Spirituality Videos ==
To demonstrate that [[Secular humanist|secular humanists]] are not just about [[debunking]], here are some videos that discuss [[secular]] visions of spirituality.
[[wikipedia:Alan_Lightman|Alan Lightman]]'s PBS series [https://searchingformeaning.org/ Searching: Our Quest for Meaning in the Age of Science] explores these topics with depth and high production values. This presentation covers the general topics. [https://www.pbs.org/show/searching-our-quest-meaning-age-science/ Watch the full series here].
{{#ev:youtube|https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MasutcQap38||center|Physicist Alan Lightman on Spirituality in the Age of Science|frame}}
<br>
{{#ev:youtube|https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L9qh0OnrcRk|Dan Dennett Secular Spirituality|center|Daniel Dennett Discusses Secular Spirituality|frame}}
{{#ev:youtube|https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L9qh0OnrcRk|Dan Dennett Secular Spirituality|center|Daniel Dennett Discusses Secular Spirituality|frame}}
<br>
<br>
Line 28: Line 79:
<br>
<br>
{{#ev:youtube|https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4ZTZQ08aWL0||center|Spirituality Amid Secularism|frame}}
{{#ev:youtube|https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4ZTZQ08aWL0||center|Spirituality Amid Secularism|frame}}
<br>
{{#ev:youtube|https://youtu.be/jAz-2Hqbipw||center|The Upbeat Atheist - My Divine|frame|start=225}}
<br>
<br>
{{#ev:youtube|https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BHOevX4DlGk||center|Police Spirits in the Material World|frame}}
{{#ev:youtube|https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BHOevX4DlGk||center|Police Spirits in the Material World|frame}}

Latest revision as of 10:57, 20 February 2025

Sacred Geometry Evokes Spirituality

Spirituality is defined here as the personal pursuit of one's core beliefs, our connections to the human community and the universe, and our efforts to help ourselves live in accordance with those convictions and connections.

This definition of spirituality has no implied belief in the supernatural, in order to allow for "secular spirituality" that is compatible with science.

"Where are our souls created during the big bang"

"It depends on what you mean by 'our souls'"

"You know what I mean by our souls." -Philomena Cunk and Brian Cox

In case you don't know what they mean by our souls, try sounding it out loud. If that doesn't work, this definition might help. The soul is the emergent property of consciousness that arises from the neurons in the brain and body, just like a hive is the emergent property of many bees working in concert. In general, spiritual terms tend to refer to emergent properties of complex systems, which is why they seem so real to believers--because they are real things! Just not material objects. We now have the terminology and theories that allow us to examine these things scientifically.

For an academic lecture from this perspective, watch The Sciences of Emergent Complexity: Evolutionary Emergence of Body, Mind, and Spirituality or one of the thousands of others like it.

Spirituality Pages

An index of pages that discuss topics related to spirituality.

It should also be noted that most of religion is simply intuitive, ritualized, psychological therapy that leverages the placebo effect. Therefore, learning about the brain and the neuroscience of consciousness and happiness is also a spiritual pursuit.

Spiritual Best Practices

Modern spirituality borrows rituals and traditions from every culture, as well as the science of psychology, to create a patchwork of religious, cultural, and secular practices that can have widely varying degrees of success.

From this there needs to evolve a more purely evidence-based spiritual tradition that illuminates the intense beauty of the universe with the inspirational, poetic language of mysticism. One that taps the power of our ancestors and practices perfected over countless generations, while providing demonstrable value with its refined rituals based on spiritual and psychological best practices.

Secular Spirituality

Spirituality need not imply the supernatural and superstitious. It can be any pursuit of self-knowledge and mental self-improvement practice. An enlightened secular spirituality can find this knowledge in any source, while maintaining a healthy skepticism for spiritual quackery that runs rampant when science and spirit are separate.

Seeking to learn the science behind ancient practices like yoga, prayer and meditation is a spiritual pursuit. Understanding exactly how rituals affect our brains and bodies doesn't demystify them or negate the placebo effect that is at the root of many health benefits.

"I celebrate myself, and sing myself,

And what I assume you shall assume,

For every atom belonging to me as good belongs to you."

-Walt Whitman, Song of Myself

While sometimes science will prove some cherished tradition to be ineffective or even counter-productive, it will back with the weight of evidence those that really help make our lives better and allow them to continue to be a part of our traditions when spiritual literalism has become a distant memory.

A Secular Spirituality Venn Diagram

Woo Without Woo

The brain's desire for wonder often leads people to the supernatural. This causes secular and scientifically minded people to refer to it derisively as "woo woo". Quantum woo is often use in attempts to add wonder to science by those who are unable to discern pseudoscience from reality.

Is there a way to infuse science with wonder while still working within the limits of materialism?

Fractal Pantheism offers a viable solution. Using fractal geometry and the universe itself as a scientific metaphor for the god concept, the beauty and wonder found in religious art and psychedelic visions throughout history is evoked, along with the infinite complexity of the evolving universe, and the fundamental, self-referential slipperiness of truth described by Gödel.

It uses a metaphor that helps ground spiritual beliefs in scientific reality, instead of supernatural ones that are too easy to take literally.

Fractals give the brain the wonder and "woo" that it craves while working fully within the framework of the laws of physics.

Secular Spirituality Videos

To demonstrate that secular humanists are not just about debunking, here are some videos that discuss secular visions of spirituality.

Alan Lightman's PBS series Searching: Our Quest for Meaning in the Age of Science explores these topics with depth and high production values. This presentation covers the general topics. Watch the full series here.

Physicist Alan Lightman on Spirituality in the Age of Science


Daniel Dennett Discusses Secular Spirituality


Sam Harris Mindfulness is Powerful


Spirituality Amid Secularism


The Upbeat Atheist - My Divine


Police Spirits in the Material World